Worst Salt & Straw Flavors: A Taste Test

Salt & Straw, a Portland-based ice cream parlor, is renowned for its innovative and unique flavors. However, not every creation hits the mark. While subjective, some flavors have left customers underwhelmed or even disappointed. Let's explore some of the worst Salt & Straw flavors, based on customer reviews and expert opinions.

It's essential to note that taste is highly personal, and what may be considered the worst by some might still be a guilty pleasure for others. This list is a compilation of the most frequently mentioned least favorite flavors, not an absolute ranking.

Unpopular Savory Flavors

Salt & Straw is famous for its savory ice cream flavors, but not all have been well-received.

While the concept of savory ice cream is intriguing, some customers find the execution off-putting. The following flavors have been among the least popular in this category:

Tomato Sorbet

This flavor, a staple in many Salt & Straw shops, is often cited as one of the worst. The tomato flavor is intense and can be off-putting, especially for those expecting a sweet treat.

Some customers appreciate its unique nature, but many find it too strange and not enjoyable as an ice cream flavor.

Bacon Sundae

Another controversial flavor, the Bacon Sundae, combines maple ice cream with bacon brittle and whiskey caramel. While some love the sweet and salty combination, others find it overwhelming and not worth the calories.

Some customers also report that the bacon flavor is too strong and overpowers the ice cream, making it less enjoyable than anticipated.

Disappointing Sweet Flavors

Even Salt & Straw's sweet flavors can miss the mark for some customers.

The following flavors have been among the most criticized in the sweet category:

Butter Beer

Inspired by the popular Harry Potter beverage, this flavor has been a disappointment for many fans. Some customers find the flavor artificial and not true to the butter beer they know and love.

Others report that the flavor is too weak, making it an underwhelming addition to the menu.

Goat Cheese Marionberry Habanero

This flavor combines sweet, tangy, and spicy elements, but the execution leaves much to be desired for many customers. The goat cheese flavor is often considered too strong and overpowers the other components.

Moreover, the habanero heat is inconsistent, with some scoops being too spicy and others not spicy enough, leading to a disappointing experience.

Despite these less popular flavors, Salt & Straw continues to push boundaries and create innovative ice cream experiences. Their ever-changing menu ensures that there's always something new to try, and even if one flavor doesn't hit the mark, there's always another unique creation waiting to be discovered.