best italian panini nyc

Best Italian Panini in NYC

By Joshua TaylorDecember 7, 2025

Craving a delicious Italian panini in the heart of New York City? You're in luck! The city that never sleeps is home to a vibrant food scene, including a plethora of authentic Italian eateries serving up mouthwatering panini. From classic combinations to innovative creations, NYC's best Italian panini spots are a must-try for any sandwich lover.

But with so many options to choose from, where do you start? We've compiled a list of the best Italian panini spots in NYC, so you can satisfy your craving with confidence. Buon appetito!

Classic Italian Panini in NYC

For those seeking traditional Italian flavors, these NYC spots serve up panini that transport you straight to the streets of Rome or Milan.

Now Open: Tommy Panini Is Brookvale's New Italian Sandwich Bar From Mariah Carey's Former Private...

Italian Food On-The-Go: Where to Grab Panino in NYC

One standout is Faicco's Pork Store in Little Italy. This historic deli has been serving up classic Italian-American sandwiches since 1900. Their panini are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and pressed to perfection. Try the Mortadella & Cheese or the Italian Combo for a taste of old-school NYC charm.

Faicco's Pork Store

Address: 260 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012

Italian Panini - 20 Best Italian Street Food - A local's guide - ShegoWandering

three people holding sandwiches in their hands with meat and veggies on the side

Website: faiccos.com

Artichoke Basille's Pizza

While known for their pizza, Artichoke Basille's also serves up some of the best panini in NYC. Their Artichoke Panini, made with artichoke hearts, spinach, and mozzarella, is a fan favorite. The crusty bread and melted cheese make for a perfect combination.

Address: 321 E 14th St, New York, NY 10003

La Cristalleria: il panino più buono del mondo dicono sia a Milano

a person holding two sandwiches in their hands

Website: artichokepizza.com

Gourmet Italian Panini in NYC

For those looking to elevate their panini experience, these NYC spots offer gourmet creations with unique, high-quality ingredients.

Check out Eataly NYC Downtown, a sprawling Italian marketplace and restaurant complex. Their Panini Bar offers a variety of gourmet panini, such as the Porchetta with slow-roasted pork, salsa verde, and pickled vegetables. The fresh, artisanal ingredients make these panini a cut above the rest.

a person holding up a large sandwich with meat and cheese on it in front of a cityscape

20 Easy Panini Recipes Packed with Flavor

two halves of a sandwich sitting on top of white paper

Easy Panini Recipe - Grilled Italian Sandwich with Mozzarella

sandwiches with meat, cheese and vegetables on a table

GRILLED ITALIAN PANINI WITH HORMEL PEPPERONI

132K views · 22K reactions | The TOP 3 sandwiches at @g_and_r_deli_ •1 The Godfather •2 The Spicy Caroline •3 The Palermo #nycfoodie #italianfood #foodies #italiandeli | Nicky Smalls

several sandwiches are stacked on top of each other

17 Panini Recipes Easy Italian Sandwich Ideas For Lunch

a poster with different types of sandwiches on it's front and back sides, including the

Panini Recipes: How to Make a Perfect Toasted Italian Sandwich Delight

Eataly NYC Downtown

Address: 101 Liberty St, New York, NY 10006

Website: eataly.com/nyc-downtown

Kesté Franckeystein

This cozy West Village spot is known for its authentic Neapolitan pizza, but their panini are also worth a visit. The Prosciutto & Arugula panini is a standout, with crispy prosciutto, fresh arugula, and creamy stracciatella cheese. The perfect balance of flavors and textures.

Address: 271 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014

Website: kestepizzeria.com

From classic Italian delis to gourmet marketplaces, NYC's best Italian panini spots offer something for everyone. So next time you're in the mood for a delicious, satisfying sandwich, give one of these spots a try. Your taste buds will thank you!